Skip to main content

The ‘A to Z’ of Gen Z - Understanding perspectives...

Posted in

 
 
I offer my 9 month old a toy that is slightly out of reach for her and what does she do?  Take it from my hand and toss it over her shoulder. After a couple of minutes she turns around to pick it up. If I offer it to her again, she repeats the behavior.  The item in question is immaterial, the behavior is consistent. When something is offered, her immediate reaction is rejection.  I have been watching this pattern for the last several weeks now and as a student of the behavioral sciences, I couldn’t help but correlate this to a lot of research I have done about the motivators of this wonderful genre of human beings who belong to Generation Z.. or Gen Z as it is more colloquially known.  The god of all things “Wikipedia” provides this following definition of Generation Z.
 
Generation Z (also known as Generation MHomeland Generation, the Net Generation, or the Internet Generation) is a common name for the group of people born from a currently undefined point in the last decade of the 20th century and the beginning of the 21st century.
 
A lot of us have children who belong to this Z Class of super humans and at the risk of sounding like I belong to a different generation (which I incidentally do, X to be precise!) I want to delve a little deeper into the inner workings of the minds of our progeny. This is not to reprimand, condone or abhor anything they do, but merely to understand so that we are able to be better parents, uncles, aunts and friends to this wonderful group of people.
 
Transitioning from a corporate role to now a full time a stay at home mom, has given me a very unique perspective into the way Gen Z seems to think, act, react and feel motivated.  When you are thinking of this generation as an employee or an employer, there is an element of impersonality that comes in and there are lines you never cross. You read the various studies and reports and go through the communication classes and exercises that teach you how to talk to a team member who belongs to Gen Z, how to make an offer or train such an individual. While you are interfacing with human likes, dislikes, frailties and emotions in dealing with such situations, as a parent, you are thinking of your Gen Z offspring quite differently.
 
You are mom or a dad first before considering their generational differences and the corresponding quirks. You assume to be right (you are the parent remember?) first before being open to dialog with a pre-teen who has more questions about stem cell research than you can hope to find answers for.  At the risk of being called “boring”, “not in”, “hard to talk to”, it is our turn to come off the “I am the parent and therefore am mighty and lofty and all I say is the law” bandwagon and open our minds to dialog and conversation. Over the years I have seen that parents who do this have the privilege of growing up with their children and teaching them in the process, as opposed to being left behind as the communication and emotional gaps widen.
 
Since I chose to have a child much later in life after fulfilling a lot of career aspirations, I have had the privilege of being “friends” with a lot of this generation, thanks to my friends and their lovely kids.  So the conclusions derived from here on in the column are partly empirical and partly conjecture. I will have my Gen Z friends validate this for me for sure !
 
The Gen Z Milieu
Put yourself into their Skechers or flip flops for a change and look at the world around you. You have brought them into world of instant gratification. Speed, change and dynamism are at the core of everything they do and see. They have not seen the progression of all the changes they see around them. Television means a zillion channels to choose from. Electronics mean every conceivable gadget that makes our lives easier.  Keystrokes are faster than learning the cursive form of writing. This generation came in at a time when the world ironically had settled into the fast pace of stability against the constancy of change.
 
The Gen Z Dilemma
So what has change done for this generation that causes them to think, act, react and focus the way they do? Change has given them the irrefutable multiplicity of options. The irrevocable plethora of choices that they sometimes take for granted not realizing if it indeed is a boon on a bane.
A friend was talking to me about her teenage son the other day and she made some very profound statements when she said, “….you know these kids have so much they listen but do not hear.” Then she went on to say while talking about this generation another astute comment, “…but I hope they figure out who they are…too much of everything is not good…they are far too exposed to everything without having the maturity to sort it out in their heads…”
I don’t disagree with her at all, but I wonder what is it that guides them to indeed “listen”, to be the shining example of the pre-teen child, a friend wrote about on Facebook today.  The child didn’t want a bed time story read to him when his father said he was too tired to read. Instead brought a book to his dad suggesting, this might help the latter get a good night’s rest.
 
The Gen Z Motivators
Here we have a generation that has everything at their fingertips, literally! They don’t have to struggle much to get information. They have brilliant minds and are not afraid to speak them.  Given all this, what makes some of them want to take on the harder courses in school, go the extra lap in the pool, find ways to take care of their family, help out with boring chores, ask the difficult questions or just show attitude more, than others?
From my limited interaction and the bit of reading I have done as a part of work related research, the first assumption we often mistakenly make about this generation is their desire to be “different”. Ironically more than the Baby Boomers or even the Generation X folks like yours truly, this group of individuals want something that is paradoxical to overt individuality. They want to experience an independent sense of belonging Yes it sounds contradictory but it is a fact.  If you look at the patterns of socialization in Gen Z, they identify themselves not only as who they are but also as a part of a larger community, be it a social networking site or a fan group of the latest rock band. They are not doing this to hide their identity, rather to prove they are an indispensable part of a larger entity, because of their identity.
They love recognition but they like to make a difference and have that be recognized. It is not enough for us to tell them, “good job”, rather take the time to see why they did, what they did. They look at life a little bit differently but they do have a desire to search of some sort of meaning in their actions. My neighbor’s daughter wanted her family to work with her and clean the yard on her birthday. She didn’t do this with a grand and glorious desire to be different but simply because she thought it would be a fun thing to do.
If they come across as lackadaisical about stuff, it is because that particular “stuff” has not appealed to them and they would rather not waste their time pursuing an subject of non-interest. This of course cannot be a fun prospect for parents because life entails we do the fun and boring stuff and enabling an Gen Z to see that even the boring stuff matters is where the challenge lies.
 
Bridging gaps… or at least, knowing they exist
Honest, upfront, direct communication is the way to go with this generation. They like to be recognized as individuals who can dish out pointed questions so it is only fair to assume they can take it, and if not then they are playing double standards and that is one thing they don’t like being accused of.  Treat them as adults and they will be expected to respond such. Easier said than done I know but the old fashioned way of one way parental speak is not going to work. You can remain delusional that it will but frankly I rather have my daughter develop a mind of her own to ask questions than taking things just at face value. If we are not in a position to answer their questions, we have not seen the bridge, let alone cross it. My pre-teen niece asked her father to not stress about her exams. Her logic, these are her exams, not his, why worry?
You see unlike a lot of us, our children will not be asking questions that begin with a “Who” or a “What”. Their questions usually will start with a “Why” or a “Why not” and those are not the ones with the easiest answers. The more you cringe as a parent, the more you alienate the ability to be their friend with parental authority. Our children as nothing against authority, in fact they appreciate and respect it but they look for meaning in what forms the basis of such authority. They want to find reasons to respect a situation or a person. Name dropping doesn’t work for them. Their sense of communal identity often goes against taking something  at face value without first having figured out the reason to do so.
As I watch my little Parijat take the toy time and again from my hand, toss it over her shoulder and then turn back to look for it and figure it out, I prepare myself for the years to come and the questions that will follow. I think back on Tennyson and a line from the Charge of The Light Brigade, and smile to myself.
 
…Their’s not to reason why, Their’s but to do and die…
 
This is the age of reason; let’s not kid ourselves by thinking otherwise. Your child is a better person for asking the right questions than not. And you are a better parent for answering them directly than not.  Enjoy the ride… I plan to.

0
Your rating: None

Good one!

Good read Pritha. I found so many similarities with this ..in the way I had been brought up and the contradiction in my upbringing of my child..I like the way you've explained it too & especially echo the last lines.." This is the age of reason; let’s not kid ourselves by thinking otherwise. Your child is a better person for asking the right questions than not. And you are a better parent for answering them directly than not."

Maitreyee

thank you

Pritha's picture

.. so much to learn from this generation I think :) glad u could relate to it..

Warm regards

Pritha

The ‘A to Z’ of Gen Z - Understanding perspectives..well written

Perhaps the Gen X (like me) would have to adapt faster to be able to have a more meaning ful conversation with the Gen Z!!!
Well written, Pritha, good article.
Ranjan

ASHADHARAN

Ki sundar observation korecho.very good analysis .

mamoni

thank you mamoni

Pritha's picture

for always encouraging me to push myself.. :)

You said it just right

Anumita Chatterjee Roy Moon's picture

Pritha, each word you wrote has truth in it. I have a teenager and a 9 year old, they both are similar yet poles apart. One thing I learnt being a mother is to treat my kids as individuals, exactly as you have written, this has not only kept communication alive between my children but I have a very active communication with my niece and nephews living across the globe. There are things they confined to me which their own parents would never know. The Gen Z, are often misunderstood as rude, but if we look at it from their angle, just as you mentioned "in their sketchers and flipflops", they are just questioning to fulfill their thirst to know and not trying to pull ranks.

Loved your write Pritha..you are a real great mom.

Anumita Chatterjee Roy (Moon)

appreciate the thoughts so much Anu

Pritha's picture

given that you relate to it and you are mom of 2 strapping Gen Z's I take that as great validation..

Sorry for the spoiler,

Sorry for the spoiler, B’khush. Here’s a piece of candid feedback (& no offense or anything personal here).
I felt that this article was extremely fake, second hand and too much of a collage of tertiary opinions, rather than an informative & first hand singular. The author (if I may call her so, at the risk of demeaning the very term itself) automatically assumes her supreme grasp on the subject and embarks upon a long and arduous journey of preaching lesser mortals on parenting and child psychology. The saving grace is that somewhere in between, she has let out the reason as well. This post reminded me of a lady at our club who became a mother at 43 (when most of her peer group had kids in their late teens or touching early 20s). Maybe so many years of anticipation and reading too much of pop psychology and parenting books / columns has led her to believe that she is an absolute authority on parenting. It’s hilarious when she starts dishing out so many parenting tips to others who are seasoned parents for decades now and with real experience.
Parenting is an important stage in personal leadership and like every lesson on leadership, it’s an ever evolving phenomenon. When a child is born, a parent is born too. As the child grows, crawls out of his /her crib, the parent too takes his / her first baby steps in parenting and the process progresses as the child loses the first milk tooth, has the first fracture, graduates from a play school to a real school, tops a class, loses a contest, falls in love, has the first heartbreak and so on and so forth. With each event (biological / psychological) that the child goes through, he / she grows a little bit – and so does the parent. Wish parenting was a magic pill available at drugstores, which people could pop in and become the most accomplished parents overnight. But then, some things in life need some real experience and a hands-on practice.
Wikipedia (useful though it may be, as an academic tool) cannot help you become a great swimmer, and similarly is not a useful place to dig into, if you want to become a great parent. These things are beyond theory. They need real working .
Our parents belonged to a generation when they were not bombarded with so much of information over doze and "expert opinions" from every unqualified expert. They relied on gut. They made mistakes, and course corrected them as they went along. And I don’t think that they did a bad job at all. The current generation of parents (the so called “evolved” and “ well read” ones) have much lower tolerance levels , despite their plastic approach to parenting.
So my only request to B’Khush would be to take in qualified experts (say- real Child Psychologists) if you need to publish psychology. Else stick to your basic format of stories, events, film reviews and entertainment. I think you have a much better pedigree of contributors under those heads.
As for your in-house “parenting guru” – My suggestion would be that she concentrates on her 9 month old now, rather than teaching the world how to connect with their kids. We have access to enough resources and have enough experience on parenting – tons more than what she has, for sure.
Cheers...

thanks so much for taking the time :)

Pritha's picture

wish you didn't keep the anonymity given you certainly seem to have a great understanding of my inadequacies as a mother, a parent, and at the risk of demeaning myself, an author, as you so lucidly put it. I am sure Antara and the B'Khush team will take your advice strongly and follow thru as needed.

Your critique is highly appreciated and I will post this on my page on Facebook for others to read and understand lest they be biased or misled by what I wrote. Again your anonymity just takes the punch out of the punch line :) but thank you anyway.. I am certain your expertise comes from raising children of your own. A lot of readers who are parents of GEN Z seemed to agree, your feedback will help them see the issue more objectively

Sincerely

Pritha

To Critique a Critic!

The above critique brought a smile on my face! The first question that popped up was 'Are you a Mom or a Dad?" An anonymous piece has no credibility as it implies that the person writing wants to hide his identity.
I have seen Pritha as a brand new Mom at 43, and it has been a pleasure watching her savour every little moment, treasure each snap taken of her little Parijat, as she lets herself evolve as a mother. She is learning every lesson on parenting live, and not from Wikipedia, from where she has taken only a mere definition! Her zest for life makes her a mother worth emulating!
Qualified experts/ Child psychologists will always expound on parenting theories, but there is nothing like a mother's touch to make it real.
Pritha does not dish out parenting tips to seasoned parents, but only expresses her own views, a fundamental right in the Constitution!
Why don't we live and let live, and respect the views of others, and not malign well meaning folks by dubbing them 'in-house parenting gurus'?
Have a good day!
Cheers,
Deepti

thanks Dips :)))

Pritha's picture

you are very kind and given you are an accomplished writer yourself, your words are more than mere compliments from a friend.. but here is an assumption that the critic made .. i am not 43 hehe.. I am 41 :)))))

And you think you are an expert?

Let me assure you lad/ladle or whoever you are, if you thought you were such an expert why didn't you come out in the open? - point one, for to me if you have to critique let's have a fair take. Your very keeping behind the scenes shows how original that thinking is. No I have no 'personal' connections with the lady who has written this, however I do have grudges who think that they are superior mortals with their writing and can degrade others. Well let me tell you all the writers who made it there have made it with their keen sense of observation and yes indeed a study of behavorial sciences. If everything had to be classified as "on hands" guru Ruskin Bond wouldn't have made it so big in children psychology and yes Jhumpa Lahiri wouldn't have written about a certain Gogol before she even got married. Being a gender studies researcher with World Bank and Indian Government let me tell you that when a person writes an observational piece the "age" category or whether the person has a hands on exp in it doesn't really matter, what matters is how well you know the subject.
I feel the article is indeed a wonderful take on the world of psychology and she's bravely attempted connecting it with the world around. By taking a dig at her age, her parental skills I think you are just showing your immaturity and yes also "OMG, how can someone write so well and I just rot wishing I could to" - it is so easy to critique - wonder if you ever channelized your energy to attempt such a nice piece!

thank you

Pritha's picture

.. feels great to be validated by writers such as yourself with powers of observation and inference that inspire people like me to hit the keystrokes on and off..

a bit of feedback from some folks on Facebook

Pritha's picture

Hi As I had mentioned I would post your thoughts on my FB page to ensure my readers received a balanced perspective and here are some of the comments from them.
 
FROM ABHILASHA TRIVEDI
So it begins with - "no offence or anything personal here", well I feel the write up is filld with a vry planned and systematic offence and personal vendetta. The person does not qualify to get the respect of a 'critique'. There are defina
tely some valid points in what this 'anonymous' 'sensitive' soul has expressed, but the expression is absolutely heartless but then I guess some people have all their sensitivity working exclusively for their benefit. Loved your point of you in your article Pritha and definately saw a new perspective to things :)
 
FROM SHILADITYA SARKAR
 
just have to say 2 things - sharing ones thought or experience is not preaching and secondly why should a critic always assume that "the piece" was only meant for those "experienced parents". I dare say, perhaps, he or she (the critic) ma
y have had some very poor record of parenting and so perhaps felt being pointed at... again my assumption, need not be 100% correct on that and open to "critique". I also did not read anything in the response by the "critic", to justify his or her comments of "fake"....just my thoughts again reading the "critique"....
 
FROM RITA DEY
 
Individuals are entitled to their versions of feedback on the topic Pritha wrote on this electronic journal. One Anonymous person sure got personal here. If a 9 month old baby's mother has the ability to foresee/ analyse teenagers, she is called a well headed person, neither an expert nor a deg. holder psychologist.
 

FROM JOANNA SMITH

 
Pritha, I enjoyed your article. As someone who has been a supervisor of members of Gen Z, I have seen those perspectives that are different than other generations - causing friction in the workplace between each group. It is important to understand the environment each grew up in so that communication styles, motivators, etc. can be appropriately used for each individual employee.
 

The critique...was poorly written. It was so sarcastic I had to read and reread several lines to try to understand what the writer was saying. All that came across was misdirected anger. Obviously this person has struggled as a parent and t
akes any intellectual commentary from others as personal criticism on their own parenting skills. Too bad, it is always difficult to have a thought provoking discourse on varying viewpoints when someone inappropriately resorts to sarcasm. Sarcasm is a vernacular used between old friends in a party/bar atmosphere...not in feedback or public discourse.

 
FROM SUDESHNA BANERJI

Pritha di, here are a few issues with the critique : a) At no point do you claim to be an expert. You were only sharing your viewpoints and observations. b) There's lack of objectivity in the critique because the person has resorted to using adverbs/adjectives at you and your ability to be a mom, thus making it personal. c) What you did was compare your notes in your field of study to what you observed in your daughter. Those who are not entirely familiar with OB/OD concepts may not be able to fully grasp your comparisons. d) It's usually not advisable to use Wikipedia as a reference primarily because their information is not always accurate and/or verified. Use a reference book/website instead for your source of definitions/facts. Our profs never allow us to use Wikipedia in our papers as reference. e) The only point that seemed agreeable with the person who critiqued your article was that parents grow with their kids and learn with them and that's just learning from experience; books/blogs can help only so much because each kid is different.
 
FROM SOWMYA SARAFF
The only point I could glean from the critique was that he/she believes that someone is qualified to advise only after they have many years of personal experience. By that logic, none of us should ever comment on books or movies if we have personally never created one in our lives. Keep going Pritha - what you say is what you believe in, I don't look at the B'Kush articles as advise columns...they are more like blogs and that is what makes them so personal and interesting. Cheers
 
FROM ADITI BANERJEE

‎..2 typos..."an impersonal" and "too emotional"
 
FROM KAUKAB BILGRAMI

Its good to take critics in good spirit & accept their views as well which my sea hearted pal has done ; here even i will agree to some degree tht yes parenting & raising kids s not an easy task & one cant follow bookish knowledge- absolute
ly NO but guess wht Pritha intended is to highlight tht we live in an e-age whre regulating kids behavior s not a cake walk unlike wht it was b4 ths hi tech times- I believe Pritha didnt mean to pin point parents mistakes in upbringing but her main aim was to bridge d gap by re-iterating tht parental rules will not help in correcting ur child's attitude instead a much mature approach i.e. treating ur kids like adults cd do wonders. Agree tht established ye using d word establishe parents who hv gone thru hell raising their child sp the NRIs who hardly had any guidance frm their own elders must hv been a tough ride but ppl like Pritha seem to just pop up to remind d already loving parents to understand & love their kids even more...... Atleast ths s wht i interpret. In a nutshell - i like critics as well:))

And the point is?

Anumita Chatterjee Roy Moon's picture

In all the above mentioned comment, I am not sure I got the point. As per my knowledge, Pritha is not trying to analyse as a psychologist, she is just putting her observations and few of her studies in a coherent format. Parents may agree to some and may not, but that does not require such a critique. This is forum of discussion, and I guess everyone has a right to state their views, we as parents ourselves have our own views about parenting. I have worked with some real good child psychologist, especially in the school district, and tell you what, they often rely on the parent to deduce what is happening. Their deduction just has some jargon we parent do not use.

Would love to hear your take on parenting too, as we are always in a learning path.

Anumita Chatterjee Roy (Moon)

Yes, Anumita. I totally agree

Yes, Anumita. I totally agree with you that Pritha is sharing her observations. Life is a huge learning curve. There is always an opportunity to adopt a different viewpoint and/or perspective.

To Critique a Critic!

The long critique of Pritha's article actually brought a smile on my face! The question I needed to ask was, "Are you a Mom or a Dad?" An anonymous piece holds no credibility as it implies that the person writing wants to hide his/her identity. Not a good thing at all!
Secondly, I have seen Pritha from a brand new Mom onwards. One thing that comes through is her sincerity in raising her little Parijat. At 43, she still wants to do the best for her baby, and she shares this with her close friends. She is a wonderful Mom waiting eagerly for her little butterfly to evolve. And if she has put down her observations on parenting, it is not out of Wikipedia[from where she has taken but a mere definition!] but out of love and experience. She plans to grow along with her little Parijat, another point in your critique.
Qualified experts/Child psychologists may give much advice on how to be a parent and what to do to make children feel loved, but there is nothing like the touch of a mother's arms to make this feeling real.
Pritha is not 'dishing out parenting tips' to seasoned parents. She is just expressing her views, which is a fundamental right under the constitution.
Wouldn't it be more civilized to hear one another out unbiasedly, and take the best from one another and leave out the rest?
Hoping you have a good day!
Cheers,
Deepti

First things first

My reply here is in reference to the above mentioned comment. I don't really think Pritha set out to educate parents here firstly...As parents every stage is a learning one, whether one is a parent to a 9 year old or 20 year old.

What she did was point out her perspective..in the end every article is a perspective while looking at the said matter objectively.

I don't recall any place, in the article that she mentions it to be a mandatory piece for all parents..All of us read so many things..we are enriched by some & some which we don't understand from our point of view we perhaps don't emulate, depending on person to person.

The reply seemed to me more of a personal attack on the author of this piece..& I shall call her author since being an author is also a matter of perspective..so if James Joyce is an author, so is Chetan Bhagat..if you don't like it don't read it..simple.

Taking out a personal vendetta on a public forum is in extremely bad taste I felt, and this not because she is a friend..I would have said this for anyone.

Maitreyee

thank you so much...

Pritha's picture

MB, like I have always maintained, your clarity of thought comes thru in everything you pen down, even this thoughtful little reply for me.. much appreciated...

Loved it, can relate so well!

I love this one, can relate so well to it. In law school I remember while working on domestic violence and child abuse I had to study a lot of behavorial sciences pertaining to kids and thus completely agree with you. The XYZ teaches us so much and it is only when we read articles like this - the things become so obvious.

Keep writing and making such valid points! As for your 9 month old, well let me say she is very lucky to have a mom like you with such brilliant insights :)

thanks so much :)

Pritha's picture

.. learning as I go :) we both are.. my little tyke and I.

First things first

Maitrayee B's picture

I am replying to the comment above criticizing the article. While criticism is fine and welcome too if done sensibly..but this seemed more like a personal attack on the author( yes she is an author..whether you like it or not..whether we like it or not authors do exist after some one like Jame Joyce exited the scene!)

No where do I see Pritha mention that this article is the last word on Parenting..she shared her experience on parenting that's all. Like any other article, some people like it some don't. But there is definitely a way of going about the usage of language especially in what is a public forum.

I also found it funny that the commentor has mentioned the age of being a mom..for heaven's sake its a free world..& what age we chose to be mums is definitely our own personal choice..should one ask the world for that?

A biased comment is as harmful as is a biased article..none of us found anything biased in the article..maybe its time to be slightly more mature and decide how biased the comment was?

I say all this not because Pritha is a friend, this applies to everyone I think.

Maitreyee

A 'CRITICAL' peice!!!.........

First, a 'yay' to all of Pritha's friends who have made it very clear to the 'critic' ALL WHAT her article was about and NOT what the lad/lady interpreted it as......would just like to add something to this....
Parenting is not just about GROWTH...as pointed out by the critic...it isn't just the case of--'the child grows everyday and so do I'! NO PARENT GROWS COMPLETELY!!! Because we don't want to!! We 'grow'only up to permissible limits within us....GROW with the child and you end up becoming a 'yaar-dost' of the child--NOT a parent. It's a very thin line and requires tremendous caution. Growth of the parent is only to a certain limit....Parenting is somewhat related to a 'tight-rope' walk....with pointed swords waiting below too....it's all about 'adjustment' ...where to draw the line and where not to succumb in that'mad rush to grow with the child'....Having read Pritha's article...I can only say that she too talks about 'adjustments'...to THINK LIKE THE CHILD IS THINKING...and then to give room for changes....I have taken the liberty to say this because I am a mother of two 14 year old twins--a boy and a girl..with diverse ideas and temparaments...where each day is a learning experience.....no matter how much I'GROW'.....I have to keep going back to think like my children...think what the child is thinking, placing myself in his/her shoes and then again thinking some more....they say that to a parent a child is always a 'child'---even our children think like that...no matter how much they grow(in the eyes of the world)..with parents they always think-"I am their baby..why are they acting like 'grown-ups' with me??!!!"...The point is just not the 'growth'--that we as parents ARE doing-but sharing ideas and thoughts with others for our own betterment.

thank you

Pritha's picture

Sharmistha, I believe this is from you, given you posted similar thoughts on my FB page... really appreciate you taking the time and putting forth your perspective which makes very valid sense.. given you are a mom of 2 strapping young 14 year olds, I value your thought process immensely as I take baby steps on this path.. pun intended of course :)

reply to your thank you

Yes, Pritha...this was from me....I had forgotten to put in my name--sorry about that...and may I also add that having known you since college...I am well aware of your gift with words---did not see you then reaching for the computer/Wikipedia to check before you said something...you didn't require any 'reference' then and I dont think you do so even now..

Sharmistha

that is so kind

Pritha's picture

.. thank you so much Sharmistha :)

Anonymous???

Both the original article and the critique have thier merits that should lead to some very worthwhile conversations - except that it is difficult to attach credibility to an anonymously posted response. In my very personal opinion, there are a couple of reasons why people do not reveal thier true identity - security and lack of conviction. The first concern is valid and the latter is concerning - because a lack of conviction translates to a weak, mirth-inducing read.
So I hope Pritha's posts recieve both applause and critique, since both are needed for her to grow as a commentator, and will also lead to fruitful discussions, and I hope that all such posts are secured by some valid id.
- Tinty.

that was my exact reply to the critic too

Pritha's picture

.. the anonymity just diluted the commentary for me.. thanks Tinty, your thoughts are much appreciated as always..

Pritha - Here's my 2 bit

AB's picture

Pritha,

Antara had requested me to check this article out ( and I see the the host of comments and counter comments thereafter) and give my neutral inputs from a dad’s point of view, given that the article (& the criticism from the lone critic) is about parenting and I daresay that a dad too is almost a 50% parent (well , I wanted to say 70%, but then most moms would disagree and give us a lesser percentage. So let me say say , almost 50 ;) Happy ? )
To start with the article, I think that it’s a pretty decent piece of writing. I like your style of writing, your choice of words , your flow of thoughts & how you weave them together. Yes, it is informative too, given the fact that every generation is different and needs to brought up differently. When we were younger, the world was simpler and maybe so was parenting. In today’s world where your child gets to know of things much before you do and can operate gadgets & extract information from the web 10 times faster than you can, you need to be agile and in sync with times to ensure that your child doesn’t fall prey to so many ills all around. I have a 13 year old daughter and I know how much concerned both of us are about the information she is exposed to (& yet she manages to stay one step ahead nevertheless and keeps laughing at her primitive parents). And though still a over protective father, I have gradually given in to my wife’s inclusive style of parenting, rather than my earlier autocratic one. I have observed that my child grows more balanced( less agitated) and responds better when we are “with” her, rather than “above” her.
Secondly, I see no reason why one cannot write on parenting without experience. That way every gynaecologist needed to be a mother first or every sexologist(or whatever they call them !) needed to have a venereal disease first and then treat a patient , right ? So no harm in sharing your knowledge / opinions if you have a flair for writing well. Your articles can always help others. As a compulsive blogger myself , I keep scribbling all the time and not every day do I write on subjects I am an expert about. But it’s more to share something that I might have heard or read and had an opinion about and wanted to toss it around . People have told me that they like those posts too, just like they like posts from my core competence area and my domain.
Lastly, to the anonymous critic – Mr / Ms X – Respect your views . But what’s the point in getting personal on such a positive website ? The author here has spent time and energy, writing a nice article ( If I know B’khush – most likely she is also doing that as a voluntary participation). If you do not like her writing , you have all the right to stop yourself from reading it. Simple – huh ? Why did you have to waste YOUR time and energy trying to dissect someone else’s effort. Would like to hear your own views on parenting too, if you don’t mind.

Pritha – Chill . Great job. And (to the critic) – This is coming from a man who became a dad at a very young age and really GREW UP with his child – but still never stops learning from anyone. Every person has a story to share and every person knows something better than we do. Thanks for some of the tips Pritha . Lemme try some on my teenager today ! Maybe finally she will consider me to be a cool dad after all !!

Ayon

thanks much

Pritha's picture

.. appreciate your comments and your analysis Ayon.. am sure you guys are doing a fabulous job with your princess :)

Rgds

Pritha

Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <img> <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options