
Been married for some time now, I wanted to know the different views all hold about this institution. In today’s supersonic world the system of marriage and its value has taken a new meaning. For the good or bad, I really cannot say, as one who lives it knows it the best. During my visit to India, I asked few ladies their views about marriage.
One of them was a 60 year old lady named Rina Chatterjee, who incidentally is my mother. My mother grew up with convent education and in a most modern atmosphere in Pune. She was married to a very conservative family living in the off skirts of Kolkata city. My Dad was a person ahead of his time; in spite of the differences they both developed a healthy family. My talk with Ma on the subject of marriage seemed to be a cliché, but every time I hear her speak, she seemed to be telling me something new. Have look at her views.
On the next instance, I chatted up a younger lady named Poulomi Bhattacharya, who had a love marriage and has a daughter of 3 years. Yes, ladies she is glowing because she is expecting again. Surprising enough, her take on the institution of marriage was not really very different from my mother’s. The only thing different was the way she handles it. Her husband is in the navy and so she is the head of the house for 6months straight. With no male member in the household, she runs the whole show. Her innocent face and her sweet appearance cannot measure her immense inner strength. Kudos to Poulomi, women like her can weather any storm in any relationship. Look at the video and I think you would agree with me.
Finally, I got a woman from a different stratum of life. Our maid named Bina. She is well known to us, and her family history is an open book. The biggest shock to me was, when she lied on camera. She covered up all the misdoing of her husband. Bina married by her own, and her husband is a petty thief. She will never word it, but it comes out in her day to day rambling. He has secretly married someone else in a registered from, making her illegal, yet she calls herself his wife. Her blatant lies, made me wonder if she really loves her so-called husband so much. As this conversation is in Bengali, I have attached a translation to my questions and answers. I apologies for the darkness of the video, as she did not agree to do the shoot out doors.
Me: Bina what is your full name?
Bina: Bina Andel.
Me: Bina are you married?
Bina: Yes
Me: When did you get married, how long are you married?
Bina: 13 years
Me: Did you marry on your own or did your parents get you married?
Bina: I married on my own.
Me: Where did you get married?
Bina: At Kalighat (the temple of Kalighat performs marriages where parents permission is not necessary)
Me: Why did you marry?
Bina: (smile and babbles)
Me: Did you fall in love and then marry?
Bina: Yes
Me: Did anyone object on your marriage?
Bina: No
Me: Who are there in your family?
Bina: My older brothers and their wives.
Me: What about your parents?
Bina: Don’t have them.
Me: So did not have problem getting married?
Bina: No
Me: Are you happy in your marriage?
Bina: Yes (to quick answer)
Me: Does your husband live with you?
Bina: Yes
Me: Are you telling the truth?
Bina: Yes
Me: How many kids do you have?
Bina: One son and one daughter.
Me: How old are they?
Bina: The daughter is 12 years and the son is 6years old.
Me: Do send them to school?
Bina: Yes
Me: Will you let them finish their education or will you get your daughter married early?
Bina: No no will let them both study.
Me: You work in household of different individuals, for what?
Bina: For the family and my kids.
Me: Now if your husband tells you to leave this work of yours to keep the marriage, would you do so?
Bina: No
Me: How long are you working?
Bina: Guess 25 years
Me: Tell, if time could take you back, and allow you to have what you have now without getting married, would that been better?
Bina: No this is better.
Me: Do your kids listen to you and who takes care of them when you are working in the evening?
Bina: They do, and my brothers are there to take care.
Me: Does your husband stay with you?
Bina: Yes, (am smiling as I know it otherwise)
Me: Bina tell me what does marriage mean to you?
Bina: (smiles away with no concrete answer while I coax her)
Me: The friends of yours who did not marry are they less happy?
Bina: For me marriage is happiness.
Me: So marriage is just have a family to you?
Bina: Yes.
Me: So if now you husband goes away to someone else will there be any difference being married or not?
Bina: No there will be no difference ( I sense her growing discomfort)
Me: So ultimately your husband being with you is the most important?
Bina: Yes
With this I wrap up it up.
Women from different walks of life, and of different ages still have one thing in common, on the subject of marriage, they expect to find happiness when the companionship is true. There are other aspects of marriage which could not be covered in this article. There is yet much to be said and heard on this subject.









piakaghar.com
livenri.com
lovely perspective..
I think our parents generation was a lot more selfless in their marriage than we are .. and I mean our mothers. Their levels of tolerance and acceptance were so much higher than ours is I think. It is a an amazing institution,was wonderful to read the different takes on it.. thanks Anu.. lovely insights..
:)
Thanks Pritha, and I quite agree with you...may be is just the way life is now..:)
Anumita Chatterjee Roy (Moon)
Interesting
Interesting ....marriage is always such a tricky subject, no wonder Bina was unwilling to be really candid. It takes a lot of gumption to thread-bare the not so pretty personal aspects of life, the most socially mobile and even the erudite don't do, so no surprises that even Bina has not.
Cheers! for many more..
Nishi Roy
:)
Thanks Nishi for your encouragement, and I completely agree with you on Bina's point. Off camera I asked her why did she lie while I was taping her, she just smiled and said you know everything, then why would you want me to tell it to you.
Anumita Chatterjee Roy (Moon)
Marriage is
Marriage is comittment,responsibility and ‘adjusting’ all rolled into one big mishmash. You have given different women’s point of view…which essentially remains the same ..albeit with minor tweeks ..to suit their immediate environment.
Arranged marriage is part of our tradition ,wherein two families equally matched on the socio- economic front take the decision to marry off their wards . It is a marriage of convenience ..and to make it a success is upto the families as a whole.
Love marriages are again the amalgamation of two individuals..who have similarities ..take the plunge and hope it works out. Again it is upto them to make things work favourably.
The common factor being that any success depends entirely on the individuals ability to cope and re-align their priorities ..
Marriage is a sacrifice for scores(majority) of women .. I truly wish and hope that women would be empowered enough to be perceived as equals and not just an ornamental trophy in the sacred institution of marriage…
Prabu
You said just the right thing
Prabu, other than being my childhood friend, I love the deep insightful visions you have on the relationship. I believe ever word you said about the whole institution of marriage, especially your male perspective was very valuable.
Anumita Chatterjee Roy (Moon)
marriage
anu ye ek ehsaas hai vishvaas hai bandhan hai jeevan sathi pyara ho to har musibat har dukh seh sakte hai hamari shaadi ke 25yrs ho gaye hai magar hum har lamha jeete hai door jane par hum ek doosre ko miss karte hai even v cry during the conversation on mobile hum ek doosre ki compny aaj bhi enjoy karte hai pyar bhari nokjhok takraar sab hota hai magar zindgi mein pyar ke itne raang hai ki kya bataun alfaaz kam padenge shaadi ek aisa sunehra sansaar hai ki lagta hai ki yahi meri jannat hai....pyar ki khushboo chaaron taraf bikhri hai.......ankhon se pati aur bachhon ki bhasha samajh lena unki har jaruraton ko dekhna ...........anu.....25saal ki yaadein simat aaye hai maine har pal mein zindgi ko jeeya hai shaadi bahut he pyara ehsaas hai kabhi milenge toh aur bataungi.........bye
Milne ki qwaish hai aap se
Aap ke in haseen lavzo ne mujhe sacche pyar ke ehesas dila di...sach me khehte hai ki pyar zindigi banati hai...aur aap ke isi 25saal ke khoobsurath si safar aap ko bahoth bahoth mubaarakh...aap se milne ki bahoth qwaish hai..aap se saadi ki wo sundar si tasveer bhi dekhni hai...:)
Anumita Chatterjee Roy (Moon)
Awesome glimpse
The interview with Bina touched me. Anumita, you have truly outdone yourself!
:)
Thank you so much, as I felt her side had the color we often do not see...:)
Anumita Chatterjee Roy (Moon)
<3
Moon Di,
tomar blog e lekha pora shuru korlam eii article ta diyei.
ar ami "obhibhuto".
sotti-i topic ta amader sobar porichito chena.. kachher.
kintu tar proti dharona-r je prokarbhed ta khub-i chhuye gelo.
Iti,
Sanhita...
Ami khoob khushi holam
Sanhita, tui je porchis ar bhalo legeche jene amar oh khoob bhalo laglo, amar ekta choto chesta chilo ai ekta chena topic niye lekhar, kintu jodi actual manush er mukhe sona jai ato beshi bhalo hoi ...tai ei video blog..thank you re..:)
Anumita Chatterjee Roy (Moon)
Got some great insights from
Got some great insights from ur blog, Anu! The interviews r very well done too! Loved ur mother's & Poulomi's views on a successful marriage. What I found amazing & very endearing 'bout both was the fact that neither had any heavenly or unreal expectations from this institution. Marriage, according to me is a relationship like any other, we just attach too much importance & expect huge things out of it, & when those expectations r not met, we r disappointed & disillusioned. Our egos get bruised and break ups happen. Have u ever wondered why the anger & disappointment is so much more when a boyfriend/ husband fails to keep up a movie date or something similar versus a sibling, relative or a friend doing the same? Ur Maa & Poulomi talk 'bout 'bout very simple things in life, like mutual respect, support, understanding, companionship, positivity, all of which I think make a strong and balanced marriage, u don't find them cribbing & complaining 'bout husbands not spending enough time with them, not taking them on expensive vacations, not being present for b'days & anniversaries kind of things etc...it was so refreshing & inspiring to hear them speak! As for Bina, I couldn't help but feel compassion towards her, even upscale marriages have so much abuse hidden but people continue to put on an act & live in a sham marriage for the fear of being judged or pitied & where a divorce would be a much more dignified & honorable decision! & Also might give one a chance for a happier future! Great work there, Anu!
Thank you very much
Rupa, thanks a ton for taking your time to read and watch this blog of mine, and I agree with you on the whole that women who are living their lives do really know that if they want happiness in the truest sense, then they need to skip the frills and live has it own meaning to everyone...Bina is right in her own way too..her love has a different meaning...:)
Anumita Chatterjee Roy (Moon)
A New Beginning
Nicely done, Anumita..
A few days ago I had posted on Facebook that there cannot be a 'good' or 'bad marriage'. The word marriage refers to the union of body, mind and spirit..So there is either a marriage or there is not..
In a sense marriage is a great leveler for most women endure the kind of marriage that poor Bina survives...in varying degrees. I counsel women from 'upscale homes' as a guest comments above and in 9 cases out of ten the man is unable to keep the balance that Poulomi aptly refers to.
I loved Poulomi's take on marriage, that it is an opportunity to start life afresh....and I agree entirely with Pritha when she says our mothers were selfless (even though I am half a generation ahead of you )
The least I can do is to nurture good sons who will keep the balance and honor the sanctity of marriage.
Mona Vijaykar,
Director, India in Classrooms; Globasaurus Program; Artizeezee
Author Illustrator, Vee Family Books; 'Watch out for the Indosaurus' musical
Am honored
Mona, am absolutely honored that you took the time to go through my post. Yes with Antara's coaxing and my own curiosity during my visit to India, I wanted to do some takes on few topics which are well known yet seen in a different perspective. Poulomi is a women of today, much younger than me, yet her balance in life is astounding. I am sure you are doing all the right things to make your sons into fine individuals. I am trying my level best with mine too. It was a treat to have your comment. Thank you.
Anumita Chatterjee Roy (Moon)
Being educated about marriage before committing to it
I'm so glad to see that Rina aunty has not only defined marriage so well but has also lived it by example; whereas in today's generation if you ask the 20-30 yr. olds the definition of marriage, they'll be stumped. When and how did this important message get lost ?
If you look at the women in their 20s who are in the matrimonial market, you get a feeling that their rush to getting married is akin to winning some kind of a contest. This holds true for majority of the women in their mid to late 20s. Once they cross 30, they seem to get into a panic mode. This matrimonial contest seems hilarious, like a mad dash to snag the first male available, get hitched and then flood their FB pages with their bridal images. Once the trophy (the groom) has been obtained and the honeymoon ends, trouble unfortunately begins.
In our society, we are so much programmed to think that a girl’s only goal is to get married regardless of her academic and/or career accomplishments. Daughters are seldom told that marriage should be an option. In majority of the cases, the girl holds no identity unless she’s standing next to a husband. Unlike Rina aunty and some of our parents, not many elders care to explain to their daughters as to why they should get married, what to expect in a marriage, how to handle difficult situations in a marriage and most importantly, what are the attributes that one should look for in a husband, ie, there's a complete lack of mentorship when it comes to marriage. The race begins with the parents groom search and ends with their child’s marriage and in many cases a divorce. People who are entering a marriage for the first time should be educated about it so that they don’t jeopardize theirs and their families’ lives. Parents need to initiate that process early on and teach their sons and daughters that marriage is a partnership that’ll have ups and downs but as long as there’s mutual trust, respect and love, they should try to overcome their hurdles. If both adults approach marriage with a sense of responsibility and ownership, then perhaps we could see lower divorce rates. Parents should also educate their kids that when the respect, trust and love disappears from a marriage, the spouses need to respect themselves and check out of the marriage. Legitimate divorces are still a taboo in our society and the society can be pretty unforgiving towards the divorced wife. Many parents go to the extent of giving their daughters an ultimatum as a result of which they are unable to break away from a toxic marriage.
Bina was a perfect example of being in denial about what her marriage is, what is right or wrong in a marriage and this has nothing to do with her impoverished background. It has to do with what she has seen growing up and what she has been taught, i.e., to accept all the negatives that come her way and never to stand up and fight the injustices. Sadly, you’ll see plenty of Binas in the middle and upper class families also.
I agree to your point
I quite agree, that marriage needs education, but then again have seen others also. My own niece is an engineer from this year, as she passed her college. She is engaged but in no rush to get married. She wants to work for some years make her own identity and then decided the date. Again, there are those kinds which you are talking about, and there are many blunders which happen. Marriage is a serious commitment which needs proper mental and physical readiness. Than you for taking your time to go through my posting and I appreciate you feed back.
Anumita Chatterjee Roy (Moon)
Very nice perspectives
Loved watching all of them and listen to their views. Your mother is so profound in her thoughts, well I didnt expect anything less, considering how amazing a lady you have turned out to be in your life, Anumita !! Rina's interview was very interesting considering what actually was the situation. Yes hats off to Poulomi who runs the house all by herself and specially being pregnant at this moment. This proves why we worship Goddess durga. Woman- a multifaceted creation of God. Dash Bhuja Dharini !!
:)
Thank you for taking your time to have a look at this posting. Yes, I believe the saying still is true..women are the cradle of civilization, and Ma made me what I am. Thank you once again..:)
Anumita Chatterjee Roy (Moon)
Marriage?
Anu,
This is a good piece and liked the way you did it. The idea is good but I would prefer if you have more people like your Mom who has a strong understanding of what she wants. I think the other two women are too weak in expressing their views. What is your view? I am interested to know.
Personally I don't believe in the institution of "Marriage" but completely agree with your mom that its 50% of each partner's contribution and friendship. You are too lucky to have a mom like this. So as long as two people can stay together and meet these requirements it is Marriage to me. It is honor and trust between two people and then extended to kids till they flew off. Your husband/partner is someone whom u can fall over when in trouble and can share everything which u are hiding from your parents and friends. This is not something you have to accept because society wants that but rather a happy journey together in life and enjoy the heavenly feelings of having kids as a result of this union.
Thank you for this good post which makes me look inside and give a thought.
Surjasikha
views
I agree ma came through strong, as she is more experienced and has seen more of life. I wanted to bring flavors from different age groups and strata of life..since the other two women. They are not week but they are what the other side is supposed to be. Life has different colors each has their own position...thanks for taking time to read Surjoshikha...I am so glad to hear your two cents in this matter.
Anumita Chatterjee Roy (Moon)
Marriage means a lot !
Marriage is a relationship that binds two people in one string. It is about connecting with someone on various levels like you have not connected with anyone else before, and it's about loyalty to each other and to your relationship. It includes many sacrifices, happiness and sorrows. Liked your mother's conversation a lot .
Mithu Dutta Sen.
:)
It is a commitment like none other..absolutely.
Anumita Chatterjee Roy (Moon)
Three women, three worlds!
I have managed newsrooms for many years. I am amazed at the ease with which you talk to people, despite the fact that you have no formal training. Notable among these are the first and the last interviews. It's not easy to talk to your mother (Rina Chatterjee) on such a subject with complete objectivity. I might have stumbled, honestly.
The last interview tells us so much about women and their pride in the institution of marriage though that person's marriage might have been tempestuous. Very gently, between the lines, you get the message across, handling it deftly. You cause no embarrassment to Bina. That's what a good journalist should do.
You caught your friend napping too. But it was so gentle that she did not feel it. Poulomi has a tough life. In an all women household things are certainly not easy. But her resolve to carry it through is indeed praiseworthy. Poulomi proves that love indeed can move mountains!
Somewhere, the three worlds of these three wonderful women meet. And the horizon is not so distant.
Keep blogging, keep reporting, ACR :)
Cheers!
Arindam Roy
Thank you Arindam
Talking to people is one thing I do good, thanks to my daddy dear's genes. Yes, my mother is a lady who holds a very broad spectrum of thinking, yet stays in the boundaries of customs. Talking with Bina about such a topic was the first thing that I wanted to do, as that side of society is one which is, either ignored or not really understood. Paolomi was the usual women with a bit of a twist. I enjoy doing such video blogs...and am out in the prowl for some more people who would like to share their thoughts with me.
Thank you once again Arindam.
Anumita Chatterjee Roy (Moon)
Yes, it's more than clear
Yes, it's more than clear that you are a wonderful conservationist. Video blog is a new genre. It's good that you chose a hitherto less traveled road, Anumita.
Cheers!
Arindam Roy
Media Studies and Consultancy
Post new comment